>What do we mean when we talk about autonomy?

>She was admitted to the hospital just before Christmas after swallowing a lethal dose of Tylenol, but she survived with medical intervention. Her reason? She was tired of being chronically sick, worried about her impaired mobility, afraid that she would have to leave her home. She felt that this was her best option for having some control over her last months. After she was stable, she was placed involuntarily on a psych hold, awaiting a court date to see if she could–as we say–be released safely back into the community. In the hospital for more than 4 weeks, she had a number of typical complications, including a foul case of antibiotic-induced diarrhea. She was pretty miserable, but sharp as a tack. She had had an interesting life, but most of her friends were dead, and she was not in touch with any family. She had paid her rent through the end of March, her hedge-bet in favor of going back home. Her medical problems qualified her for hospice care, but she was afraid to even talk about hospice, as she felt “they might hold it against me”. She felt ashamed and inhibited, eager to talk about her life, but hesitant to express her present state of distress. She was released to a nursing home on January 19th , court date still looming over her.

A social worker visited her at the facility, felt that she was depressed and recommended ongoing counseling. He based this assessment in part on a self-administered survey in which she circled yes to “feeling lonely, sad, blue, or depressed”; “anxious or worried”; and “having thoughts of dying or committing suicide.” She also assented to the following: “feeling like something bad is going to happen”. This was on January 22. She died of chronic heart and lung disease on January 24th in the nursing home. Thankfully, her advance directive was honored.

On February 2, this note was placed in the medical record: “Request that the restrictive order be dismissed. Patient has expired.”

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to >What do we mean when we talk about autonomy?

  1. >WOW! What an amazing story. I often wonder what autonomy really does mean. I have had many similarly interesting situations where a classic medical bioethics definition of autonomy does not seem to fit so easily as it may in a textbook. I came across an fasicnating definition of autonomy that included relationships with other people. The author defined autonomy consisting of self/desires; others/responsibilities, self&others/rewards and expectations.It helped me understand autonomy in a much different light.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s